Fidelis’ FEA services team has helped customers with a whole host of different engineering challenges, utilizing simulation to provide invaluable design direction and reduce product development costs. Here, we take a look at just one example of that, with the goal of highlighting our capabilities, process and, ultimately, the value we provided to the customer.
We all know that simulation is capable of providing insights into a large number of design iterations quickly and efficiently. This analysis exemplifies exactly that – and how the results allow selection of optimum designs prior to any physical testing. Of course, we can’t include the real results of the analyses – NDAs are important – but a simplified version shows what the results looked like.
Problem Statement
The customer (a prominent medical company with expertise in biomaterials and drug delivery systems) came to Fidelis as they were optimizing the shape and size of their new gastro retentive medicine delivery system. They were able to provide the data of different geometric shapes and size limitations for the retentive elastomers as well as the material properties of the elastomer. The concern, from their point of view, was breaking of the medicine elastomer while folding and premature passing of the medicine through the sphincter without the medicine being completely released, which can be possible due to force applied by stomach contents on the medicine.
Methodology
The DOE of the folding of the medicine, fitting it in the capsule and relaxation of the medicine inside were simulated using Abaqus explicit/dynamic solver. The capsule size was fixed and the elastomer shape and dimensions had to optimized based on this. For folding the capsule, appropriate displacement and rotation boundary conditions were applied to the elastomer nodes. Once it was folded, it was placed in a rigid capsule by moving the two ends of the capsule in opposite direction until it reached a fixed capsule closed length. All the boundary conditions on the elastomer were released and it was allowed to relax in the capsule to attain an optimal shape. A subsequent analysis was performed, known as a funnel test, to evaluate the forces required to push the elastomer in different orientations through sphincter. The customer was primarily interested in comparing the performance of elastomers with different geometries.
Another key aspect of these analyses was the material properties. The customer provided us with the experimental uniaxial tensile test data for the elastomer. The experimental data was highly nonlinear, and the material was assumed to have nearly incompressible behavior. Different hyperelastic constitutive models such as Neo Hookean, Arruda-Boyce, Yeoh, Vander Waals and Marlow were fitted to the experimental data and the final material model which best correlated with the experimental data was selected.
Results and Conclusions – Our Value
Once all of the different geometric shapes were analyzed for folding , we were able to present the customer with both stress and strain data as well as a visual image of the relaxed elastomer in the capsule. They were also provided with the force required to push the elastomer through the sphincter for different orientations. This allowed them to identify the best geometric shape for the medicine. Once this shape was identified, the dimensions of this final medicine were optimized using design of experiments by minimizing the strain in elastomer, maximizing push out force and maximizing the volume of the medicine in the capsule. All of this reduced customer prototyping and experimenting expenses by 10s of thousands of dollars. A final design decision was made based on the outcome of the DOE analysis, all without any costly physical prototyping and experimenting.
TL;DR
Fidelis was able to provide valuable insights, with the use of DOE methodology, into the behavior of various drug delivery designs . The design was refined such that both the insertion of the system into the capsule and the behavior within the body were optimized, all without any costly physical prototyping.