Fidelis’ FEA services team has helped customers with a whole host of different engineering challenges, utilizing simulation to provide invaluable design direction and reduce product development costs. Here, we take a look at just one example of that, with the goal of highlighting our capabilities, process and, ultimately, the value we provided to the customer.
We all know that simulation is capable of providing insights into a large number of design iterations quickly and efficiently. This analysis exemplifies exactly that – and how the results allow selection of optimum designs prior to any physical testing. Of course, we can’t include the real results of the analyses – NDAs are important – but a simplified version shows what the results looked like.
Problem Statement
The customer (a prominent take-out box manufacturer) came to Fidelis as they were in the process of reducing the wastage of their raw materials while making their signature take out containers by optimizing the design dimensions and materials. They were able to provide the material properties for different grades of foam under consideration as well as the initial CAD. The concern, from their point of view. was premature buckling of the material and opening of the latch due to the forces applied by the food placed in the container. Since the manufacturing process introduces variability into the final product dimensions and material properties, the customer also wanted to identify the tolerance range for the box that meets product requirements. Two standard tests had to be performed using simulation on the container with different wall thicknesses to address buckling and latch strength issues.
Methodology
A high fidelity, nonlinear ABAQUS FEA model was constructed to represent the container (lid and box) using shell elements. The lid was folded in a strain free manner to capture the physical behavior of the container closely. To capture the change in stiffness of the container as it deflected under the applied loads, nonlinear geometry was used. The crush test was first performed using the ABAQUS explicit/dynamic solver to understand the loads that the box can withstand when stacked upon one another. For this, the bottom of the box was fixed in all DOF, and downward displacement was applied at appropriate locations on the lid of the box though a rigid plate.
the second analysis was performed to evaluate the strength of the T bone and latch when the box was fully loaded with food and held from one corner. The load from the food in each of the compartments was applied through a mass element with distributed coupling. One of the corners (lid and box) was constrained in all DOF to replicate holding of the box in a person’s hand. Again, ABAQUS Explicit was used to simulate this process. To capture the directional variation of material properties of the foam, an orthotropic material model was used. Hill potential was used to model the nonlinear material behavior of foam in all three orthogonal directions.
Results and Conclusions – Our Value
Once all of the different thicknesses were analyzed for the container with different material grades, we were able to present the customer with stress and strain data on the box as well as an animation of the containers behavior when subjected to the crushing process. They were also provided with crush force data based on the first buckling mode of the box. The stress and strain distributions on the box were provided when the food was placed in each of the compartments to assess the structural integrity of the box and latch in a fully loaded condition. All of this data helped the customer to identify the upper and lower bounds on the material grade and wall thickness to meet the specified load carrying and latch security requirements for the box. This also reduced the prototyping and experimenting expenses by 10s of thousands of dollars. The customer was able to establish a final optimum design with clearly defined tolerances on the box’s material properties and thickness by using the results from our FEA model.
The study is a good example of using nonlinear simulation to reduce physical prototyping while defining a robust manufacturing design window.
TL;DR
Fidelis was able to significantly reduce the design cycle and failure rate of a polystyrene food container by using explicit/dynamic analysis to simulate crush and stiffness testing. The design was refined such that both function and material usage were optimized, all without any costly physical prototyping.